Introduction
Medical negligence occurs when healthcare professionals or providers fail to deliver appropriate treatment, take necessary actions, or provide substandard care, resulting in harm, injury, or even death to a patient. This article will focus on the concept of medical negligence from the perspective of Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), its legal implications, tests to determine negligence, and relevant forums for seeking justice.
Legal Definition and Characteristics:
For a claim to be considered medical malpractice under the law, it must possess specific characteristics:
1. Violation of the Standard of Care:
- Healthcare professionals are expected to adhere to the accepted medical standards.This adherence is known as the "standard of care."
- If the standard of care is breached, establishing a case of negligence becomes possible.
2. Injury Caused by Negligence:
- Mere violation of the standard of care is not sufficient. The patient must prove that an injury occurred due to negligence.
- An unfavorable outcome alone doesn't qualify as malpractice; a direct link between negligence and injury must be established.
3. Resulting in Significant Damages:
- Medical malpractice cases involve substantial litigation costs, requiring expert testimony and hours of deposition.
- For the case to be viable, the patient must demonstrate that the injury led to considerable damages, such as disability, loss of income, or severe pain and suffering.
Let us see some potential hypothetical examples of medical negligence:
1. Delayed Treatment:
- A patient with a severe infection seeks medical attention, but the healthcare provider delays treatment, resulting in the infection spreading and causing complications.
2. Anesthesia Errors:
- During surgery, an anesthesiologist administers an incorrect dosage or fails to monitor the patient's response adequately, leading to anesthesia-related complications.
3. Inadequate Informed Consent:
- A surgeon fails to thoroughly explain the risks and potential complications of a procedure to the patient, depriving them of the necessary information to make an informed decision.
4. Equipment Malfunction:
- The malfunction of medical equipment during a procedure, such as a surgical tool or monitoring device, causes harm to the patient due to negligence in maintenance or oversight.
5. Infections Due to Unsanitary Conditions:
- A patient develops an infection after surgery because the operating room or medical instruments were not adequately sterilized, highlighting negligence in maintaining a sanitary environment.
6. Psychiatric Malpractice:
- In the field of psychiatry, a professional prescribes incorrect medications or fails to recognize and address severe mental health issues, leading to worsened conditions or unforeseen side effects.
7. Birth Injuries:
- A healthcare provider mishandles the delivery process, leading to birth injuries such as cerebral palsy or Erb's palsy due to improper techniques or lack of timely interventions.
8. Medication Allergies Oversight:
- A doctor prescribes medication without checking the patient's allergy history, resulting in an allergic reaction and severe complications.
9. Lack of Monitoring During Recovery:
- After a surgical procedure, inadequate monitoring during the recovery period leads to complications that could have been prevented with proper postoperative care.
10. Incorrect Blood Transfusion:
- A patient receives the wrong blood type during a transfusion due to clerical errors or inadequate verification procedures, leading to life-threatening complications.
Medical Negligence in BNS:
Under Section 106 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), causing death by negligence is addressed. The section stipulates imprisonment for a term up to five years, shall also be liable to fine, if a person causes death due to a rash or negligent act not amounting to culpable homicide.
It's also provides a separate punishment for medical professionals which was not there in Indian Penal Code previously. It says that if such act is done by a registered medical practitioner while performing medical procedure, he shall be punished with imprisonment of up to two years, and shall also be liable to fine.
Tests to Prove Medical Negligence:
1. Bolam Test:
- Originating from the case of Bolam v Friend Hospital Management Committee (UK, 1957).
- Asserts that a doctor is not negligent if their actions align with accepted medical practice recognized by a responsible body of medical professionals.
2. Bolitho Test:
- Applied when a body of expert opinion lacks logical support.
- Challenges the Bolam test by emphasizing that expert opinions must be critically examined for logical validity.
3. Informed Consent:
- Ensures disclosure of risks and alternatives to meet the criteria of informed consent.
Legal Recourse for Victims:
Victims of medical negligence have multiple avenues for seeking damages:
1. Criminal recourse: A criminal case can proceed and punishment can be given as per Section 106 BNS
2. Civil Court: Traditional legal recourse involves filing a civil suit.
3 Consumer Court: Patients can approach consumer courts for compensation.
4. Human Rights Commission: In cases where human rights are violated, approaching the Human Rights Commission is an option.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) on Medical Negligence:
Q1: What is medical negligence?
A1: Medical negligence occurs when healthcare professionals or providers fail to deliver appropriate treatment, take necessary actions, or provide substandard care, resulting in harm, injury, or even death to a patient.
Q2: What are the characteristics of medical malpractice under the law?
A2: For a claim to be considered medical malpractice, it must involve:
- Violation of the Standard of Care
- Injury Caused by Negligence
- Resulting in Significant Damages
Q3: Can an unfavorable outcome alone qualify as medical malpractice?
A3: No, an unfavorable outcome alone doesn't qualify as malpractice. There must be a direct link established between negligence and injury.
Q4: How is medical negligence addressed in Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS)?
A4: Under Section 106 of BNS, causing death by negligence is addressed. It stipulates imprisonment for up to two years and a fine. For registered medical practitioners, a separate punishment is outlined.
Q5: What are some examples of medical negligence?
A5: Examples include delayed treatment, anesthesia errors, inadequate informed consent, equipment malfunction, infections due to unsanitary conditions, psychiatric malpractice, birth injuries, medication allergies oversight, lack of monitoring during recovery, and incorrect blood transfusion.
Q6: What tests are used to prove medical negligence?
A6: Two prominent tests are the Bolam Test, emphasizing adherence to accepted medical practice, and the Bolitho Test, challenging expert opinions lacking logical support. Informed consent is also a crucial aspect.
Q7: What legal recourse do victims of medical negligence have?
A7: Victims can seek damages through various avenues:
- Criminal recourse under Section 106 BNS
- Civil Court
- Consumer Court
- Human Rights Commission
Q8: Can a registered medical practitioner face different consequences under BNS?
A8: Yes, BNS provides a separate punishment for registered medical practitioners if death occurs due to a rash or negligent act while performing a medical procedure.
Q9: How does the law address the cost of pursuing medical malpractice cases?
A9: The patient must demonstrate that the injury led to considerable damages, such as disability, loss of income, or severe pain and suffering, to make the case viable.
Q10: Can patients approach consumer courts for compensation in cases of medical negligence?
A10: Yes, patients can approach consumer courts as one of the avenues for seeking compensation for damages due to medical negligence.
Medical negligence under BNS (Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita)
Comments